A friend bought a brand new Tesla in 2023 for $60,000. It's now worth $35,000. That $25,000 Tesla depreciation hit over three years works out to $700 a month before you even add Tesla financing charges.
The Numbers Don't Lie
This isn't some rare horror story. Tesla prices swung hard in 2023, with Model Y Long Range models topping $66,000 and Performance versions hitting $70,000. Drive any new car off the lot and it drops 10-20% instantly. Keep it three years and many owners see 40-50% total loss. Tesla just gets called out more because of constant price cuts and market swings.
Lease vs Buy Tesla: Which Actually Wins?
If you're keeping the car under five years, leasing often beats buying outright. A current Model 3 lease at $329 a month can come in under the depreciation curve. You pay down the balance without owning the full loss when you hand it back. Buying new locks you into the steepest part of the curve plus interest.
Used Tesla worth it deals appear when you target 1-2 year old inventory. A 2022 Model Y listed around $29,000 while the same new model sits near $45,000. The gap narrows once you factor in higher used-car interest rates versus Tesla's current 0.99% financing on new inventory. Run your own math on total cost over four years before deciding.
How to Cut the Monthly Loss
Hold any Tesla ten years and the per-month hit drops dramatically. Even a 2019 Model 3 still carries $10-15k residual value. The real game is matching your timeline to the financing or lease terms. Short-term owners should lean toward low-mileage used examples or strong lease deals. Long-term owners can absorb new-car pricing when rates stay under 1%.
Check current lease and used inventory numbers here before you commit.
When Used Makes More Sense
Cash buyers usually come out ahead on 1-2 year old Teslas. You skip the first big drop and still get recent hardware. Financed buyers need to compare the 0.99% new rate against typical 5-6% used rates to see which monthly payment actually wins.
See my latest take on whether used Tesla worth it right now.
Final Take
Don't buy a new Tesla if your plan is to flip it in three years. The depreciation hit plus Tesla financing charges will sting. Lease the Model 3 if you want the lowest monthly outlay, or shop recent used examples if you're paying cash. Either path beats absorbing the full new-car loss. Run the exact numbers for your situation and timeline.
Tesla referral — 3 months free FSD + low APR financing
Plug Motors — get an instant offer to sell your Tesla or EV
Some links are affiliate links that support the channel at no cost to you.
