Tesla Prices Gone Wild: Used Model Y More Expensive Than New? Plus Top Accessories

Tesla Prices Gone Wild: Used Model Y More Expensive Than New? Plus Top Accessories

Hey everyone, DennisCW here! If you've been shopping for a Tesla lately, you've probably noticed something bizarre: used Tesla prices are making absolutely no sense. In today's video, I broke down why a lightly used Model Y is selling for more than a brand-new one, debated if Teslas are truly "affordable," celebrated the Model 3's 10-year anniversary, and shared my top accessory picks. Let's dive in!

Used Model Y Priced Higher Than New? What Gives?

Check this out: CarMax is listing a Tesla Model Y Rear-Wheel Drive (RWD) with just 8,000 miles for $44,000. Meanwhile, a brand-new Model Y RWD straight from Tesla starts at $39,990 (plus destination fees and taxes, which won't push it over $44k).

Why the premium on the used one? Rising gas prices might be driving demand for EVs sky-high, making Teslas feel more valuable than ever. Plus, Tesla's offering 0% or 0.99% financing right now (as of this post—act fast!). If you're ordering, don't forget a Tesla referral code (link in the description below) for up to 3 months of Full Self-Driving (FSD) free.

Unless you're paying cash or love CarMax's warranty, why pay $4k+ more for a used car? Demand is real, but new from Tesla wins for value.

Is a $530/Month Model Y "Affordable"?

I saw a post claiming: "A new Model Y is $530/month for 72 months—Teslas have never been more affordable!" With 0% financing on the base model, it's a solid deal. But is it affordable for everyone?

• Pro: Average new car payment in Q4 2025? $767/month. A Model Y at $529 is below average!
• Con: Insurance can sting. One viewer quoted $400/month for Model Y insurance vs. $110/month for a Hyundai Ioniq. EVs like the EV6 or Ioniq might offer better deals.

Check our insurance tracking sheet—thousands of Tesla owners have shared their rates. Input yours and shop around to save!

Chad's take: "Value ≠ affordability." Spot on. If insurance or payments are tight, explore other EVs.

Happy 10th Birthday, Model 3!

Believe it or not, the Tesla Model 3 turns 10 years old this year. It brought Tesla mainstream, proving EVs could be affordable and fun. From S/X pioneers to mass-market hit—cheers to a decade of disruption!

Pro Tip: Cash In on Past Accidents with True Claims

Hate leaving money on the table? If you've had a car accident in the last 3-5 years, file a diminished value claim via True Claims (link below). Even repaired cars lose value due to Carfax. Some get $2k–$20k back—takes minutes for a free report, and they connect you with lawyers if needed.

My Top 3 Must-Have Tesla Accessories

Congrats on your new (or soon-to-be) Tesla! Now, level it up with accessories. My top picks:

1. All-Weather Floor Mats (My #1 rec!)

   • Good: Amazon basics.
   • Better: Lakeside Tasmanian.
   • Best: 3W Liners (use my promo code for deals—same price as others, premium quality). We use them on our Model X and Model 3 Performance.

2. Phone Mounts – Essential for navigation.

3. Center Consoles – Tesla skips these; Jowua ones are perfect (links below).

Full list + discounts on our Best Deals Spreadsheet (Page 2). Thanks for using my links—it supports the channel!

What Do You Think?

Used prices crazy? Model Y affordable? Drop your thoughts in the comments. New Tesla owner? Share your insurance/payment deets to help the community.

Thanks for reading/watching—subscribe for more Tesla tips! 🚀

Disclosure: Affiliate links may earn commission. Not financial advice.