Used Tesla Prices Are Ridiculous: Tesla vs. Dealerships & My Buying Strategy

Used Tesla Prices Are Ridiculous: Tesla vs. Dealerships & My Buying Strategy

Hey everyone, DennisCW here! If you're in the market for a used Tesla, you've probably noticed something wild: Tesla's used prices are sky-high compared to dealerships. A 2024 Model Y from Tesla? Close to $40K. The same year model from local dealerships? As low as $33K. That's a $7,000 difference! Does Tesla think their cars don't depreciate anymore? Let's break it down, compare strategies, and share where I'd shop for a used Tesla today.

The Shocking Price Gap

Take this post from Prize Means as an example:

"Why is there such a big gap between used Tesla inventory and used dealership prices? The only 2024 Tesla Model Y I see from Tesla are close to 40K. Meanwhile, there are multiple dealerships around me selling for 2024s for 33k."

Valid point! And here's the kicker: For just $5K more than a used Tesla, you could snag a brand-new Juniper Model Y. Who pays $40K for a "used" legacy model?

Why Does Tesla Charge So Much?

Tesla isn't crazy—they can charge premium prices because:

• Brand power: Tesla buyers trust the name.
• Lease residuals: They hold high values to avoid tanking new lease deals. It's a catch-22—if used prices drop too low, new leases suffer.
• Extra perks: Full inspection, 1 extra year/10K miles warranty on top of the standard 4-year/50K-mile factory warranty, and in-house financing.

But is that worth $5K–$7K extra? Most dealerships offer limited warranties too. I'd skip Tesla's inventory unless you crave that peace of mind or better rates.

The Sweet Spot: 2-Year-Old Teslas

My #1 rule? Target 2-year-old Teslas around 25K miles. Why?

• Hardest depreciation hits early—biggest discounts here.
• Remaining factory warranty: Still 2 years/25K miles left.

Example: Cam Casey bought a 2022 Model S Plaid for $125K (3K miles). Three years and 30K miles later? Worth $50K. That's a $75K loss! High-end models like Plaids depreciate fastest.

Market Outlook: Flat for the Next 4 Months

Don't expect deals soon. Used Tesla prices stay flat through spring because:

• New year vibes—everyone wants fresh rides.
• Tax season refunds fuel down payments ($4K–$5K).

Patience pays off post-spring.

My Personal Strategy: Where to Shop

1. Skip Tesla's site unless financing seals the deal (their rates might beat 6–8% elsewhere vs. 2.99% on new cars—do the math!).

2. Facebook Marketplace: Great for private sellers. Dealers post here too (watch for scams like that "$6K 2025 Model Y" nonsense), but real owners are motivated.

3. Negotiate hard: Sellers have two options—trade to sites like Plug (wholesale offers, sometimes beating Tesla) or private sale (+$1K–$2K). Offer just above their Plug quote.

Financing Tip: Protect Your Credit First

Before applying, safeguard your score. Bank of America just had a data breach—they waited a month to notify. Companies average 277 days to report!

That's why I use Aura (today's sponsor). It scans the dark web for your info, cuts spam calls, removes data from brokers, and includes $5M identity theft insurance. One clean app. Try 14 days free at aura.com/denniscw. Protect before you apply—it's like Sentry Mode before the keying.

Final Thoughts

Used Teslas are a steal outside Tesla's lot, especially 2-year-olds. Shop smart, negotiate, and time it right. What's your used Tesla strategy? Drop thoughts below—new, used, or lease?

If you enjoyed this, subscribe to my YouTube for more Tesla tips! 🚀

DennisCW