The brutal $25,000 Tesla depreciation hit
My friend bought a brand new Tesla in 2023 for $60,000. It's now worth $35,000. That $25,000 loss in three years works out to $700 a month — and that's before financing costs. This is exactly why I tell people don't buy new Tesla right now.
Tesla Model Y depreciation has been brutal because of repeated price cuts and shifting incentives. The same story plays out across the lineup. A 2022 used Tesla Model Y now sits around $29,000 while a comparable new one lists near $45,000. The gap only widens once you factor in higher interest rates on used inventory.
Tesla lease vs buy reality check
Leasing changes the math completely. Right now a Model 3 lease can be had for $329 a month. That number often beats the monthly depreciation you would eat by buying new and selling in three years. Tesla lease vs buy comes down to how long you plan to keep the car. If you're the type who upgrades every few years, leasing locks in the loss instead of letting it snowball.
Buying used Tesla instead gives you another path. A one- or two-year-old Model Y can save you $5,000–$10,000 off the new price while still delivering nearly identical hardware. Just compare the financing: new inventory sometimes carries 0.99% APR, while used rates sit closer to 5–6%. Run both scenarios before deciding.
Counterarguments worth acknowledging
Some buyers will keep their Tesla for seven to ten years. In that case the monthly depreciation hit spreads out and a new purchase at low APR can make sense. Others simply want the latest hardware or the peace of mind of a full factory warranty. Those are valid reasons, but they still don't erase the upfront depreciation that hits the moment you drive off the lot.
New Tesla waste of money isn't universal advice — it's situational. If you can find a strong lease deal or a lightly used example that fits your budget, the numbers usually favor skipping the brand-new purchase.
My bottom line
Don't buy new Tesla unless the monthly payment beats what you'd lose to depreciation anyway. For most people the smarter move is either a short-term lease or buying used Tesla instead. The data keeps showing the same pattern: the biggest savings come from letting someone else absorb that first-year drop.
If you're thinking about selling your current Tesla to make the switch, Plug Motors — get an instant offer to sell your Tesla or EV is worth checking. And if you're still leaning toward new inventory, use Tesla referral — 3 months free FSD + low APR financing to stack the incentives.
For more on timing used purchases, check out should you buy used Tesla now.
Some links are affiliate links that support the channel at no cost to you.
